ND Expert Daniel Graff on potential UAW strike: ‘We all have a stake in these negotiations’

As the strike deadline looms at 11:59 p.m. on Thursday (Sept. 14) for 146,000 members of the United Auto Workers union, many have termed “audacious” the union’s call for significant wage increases, a four-day workweek and a “just transition” for workers moving to EV production, which requires less labor than conventional cars.

As both sides ramp up efforts to seize the opportunity to advance in collective bargaining, Daniel Graff, director of the Higgins Labor Program at the University of Notre Dame, noted that the strong economy and demand for new vehicles, alongside the uncertainty of technological change, has put both the union and the corporations in a position of strength.
“Whether or not the union’s demands are realizable in this bargaining round, it is interesting to note that many of the UAW’s earlier calls for converting more productivity and profit gains into workers’ wages and benefits met with similar initial reactions,” said Graff, who has a joint faculty appointment in the Department of History and the Center for Social Concerns.
“Now many, though not all, of those ‘audacious’ demands have been redefined as essential components of a ‘good job’ today.”
The current contract negotiations are reminiscent of those in the heyday of American unionism from 1945 to the 1960s, Graff said, with UAW’s new president Shawn Fain seeming to “channel the ghost” of legendary UAW leader Walter Reuther, who helped bring about company-paid health care, pensions, paid vacations, supplemental unemployment benefits and cost-of-living adjustments to autoworkers — making them the best paid and most secure workers in the United States in the post-World War II era.
“Fain’s militant rhetoric, charging the Big 3 with greed in its refusal to share more of its recent profit gains with workers, recalls Reuther’s frequent spars that automakers hoarded ‘excess profits’ at the expense of the rank and file and the broader public as well,” Graff said.
At the same time, he noted, this is a very different moment for both sides. In the 1950s, the UAW was the largest, most powerful union in the country, GM was the world’s biggest corporation, and trends in auto employment often produced spillover effects throughout the economy.
Today, the UAW is much smaller, and the auto sector is facing “an existential crisis” brought on by global competition and climate change, he said.
“On top of the competition from cars produced abroad and those made in the U.S. by non-union competitors, the industry is faced with pressing demands to curtail greenhouse gasses as we all ramp up the efforts to fight climate change,” he said. “In the transition to electric vehicles and the calls for more mass transit, we all have a stake in the outcome of these negotiations.
“Whatever the result — which many see as inevitably leading to a rare simultaneous strike of the Big 3 — perhaps we should thank the UAW for reinvigorating the public conversation around what we expect from corporations and good jobs in the 21st century.”
Latest Faculty & Staff
- ‘Woman the hunter’: Studies aim to correct historyNew research from Cara Ocobock, an assistant professor in the Department of Anthropology and director of the Human Energetics Laboratory at the University of Notre Dame, combined both physiological and archaeological evidence to argue that not only did prehistoric women engage in the practice of hunting, but their female anatomy and biology would have made them intrinsically better suited for it.
- In memoriam: Thomas J. Schlereth, emeritus professorThomas J. Schlereth, a longtime professor of American studies at the University of Notre Dame and author of a widely read in-depth history of the University, died Saturday (Nov. 11) at Ernestine M. Raclin House for hospice care in Mishawaka. He was 82. The oldest of five children and raised in the north hills of Pittsburgh, Schlereth enrolled at Notre Dame in 1959 and graduated in 1963 with a bachelor’s degree in history. He earned his master’s degree at the University of Wisconsin and his doctorate at the University of Iowa.…
- Thomas O’Sullivan takes first, Tengfei Luo second, in 1st Source Bank Commercialization AwardsThomas O’Sullivan, associate professor of electrical engineering at the University of Notre Dame, is the first-place winner of the 2023 1st Source Bank Commercialization Award. Tengfei Luo, the Dorini Family Professor for Energy Studies, placed second.
- In memoriam: Michael Montalbano, adjunct assistant teaching professorMichael Montalbano, adjunct assistant teaching professor at the Mendoza College of Business, passed away unexpectedly on Tuesday (Nov. 7) at his home in South Bend, Indiana. He was 66.
- Democracy in darkness: Notre Dame historian explores the role of secrecy in representative governmentThere are lessons to be learned from democracy’s shadowy origins about both the dangers and potential utility of secrecy in a representative government, said Katlyn Marie Carter, an assistant professor of history. In new research, Carter explores how debates over secrecy and transparency in politics during the Age of Revolutions shaped modern democracy — and how they can shed new light on current examples of political misconduct.
- Acclaimed teaching scholar James Lang joins Notre Dame Learning’s Kaneb CenterJames M. Lang, the author of several popular books on teaching, including “Distracted: Why Students Can’t Focus and What You Can Do About It” and “Small Teaching: Everyday Lessons from the Science of Learning,” has joined the faculty of the University of Notre Dame through September of next year.